
How the case begins
In the footsteps of Geneva Tolan
Hartley's has sold gloves, hats and good perfume on Riverside Avenue in Spokane, Washington, since 1889. On Thursdays the store stays open until nine. Every sale at the perfume counter goes into the counter book, on a numbered slip with a carbon page under it. The customer takes the top copy, and the carbon stays in the book. At nine the cash goes up the tube to the cash office, and on Friday morning the cash office checks it against the book. Since the first of June, the perfume counter has come up short every Thursday, by exactly forty-one dollars. That is the price of the big bottle of Nuit de Mai. Each week the book shows one sold for cash, on a slip initialed G.T. Geneva Tolan works the counter on Thursday nights. She has never sold a big Nuit de Mai for cash in her life. The best part of her Thursdays this summer has been Clark Reilly, up from Seattle, who stops at her counter every week. On Thursday, August 3, Mr. Hartley put marked bills in her drawer and had a man watch the counter until half past nine. Every marked bill reached the cash office. On Friday morning the book was forty-one dollars short again. Mr. Hartley has given Geneva until next Friday. She wants to know whose hand is writing her initials.
- 1Slip 5209
- 2Twelve in May
- 3Sweet Peas
- 4Crusts for the Ducks
- 5Subject Left at 9:05
- 6Let the Bus Go
- 7Something Lighter
- 8Supper on Five
- 9Five to Nine
- 10A Quarter to Tenbring your clues
Each chapter is a short scene and a puzzle, and each puzzle leaves Geneva one clue. Keep all nine for the finale.
Prefer pen and paper?
The whole case as one large-print booklet: every chapter and its puzzle, a clue ledger to fill in, and the ending sealed on the last page.
The people of the case
- Geneva Tolan. Has sold perfume at Hartley's since 1946. Lives with her mother on the South Hill.
- Clark Reilly. Comes over from Seattle on business most weeks. Stays at the Norden Hotel on First Avenue.
- Everett Dowling. Floorwalker on Hartley's main floor since 1938. Wears a fresh carnation every morning.
- Irma Kirby. Hartley's buyer for perfume and toilet goods. Has a desk at the back of the stockroom.
- Barney Stahl. Night watchman at Hartley's since 1931. Keeps a canary in the boiler room.
- Mr. Hartley. Owns Hartley's, which his grandfather opened in 1889.



